[tab:Match report]
Motherwell suffered an agonising defeat in their opening league game of the season as Hibs came from behind to win at Fir Park.
The Steelmen took the lead through John Sutton on 13 minutes and looked set for victory after a dominant first-half performance.
But Anthony Stokes equalised on the stroke of half-time for Hibs and Paul Hanlon controversially put them in front midway through the second-half.
Liam Miller then made it 3-1 before Jamie Murphy pulled one back from the spot in what was another entertaining clash between the two sides.
Craig Brown kept faith with the same team that overcame Aalesund in the Europa League ten days earlier.
That meant new-boys Nick Blackman and Esteban Casagolda had to be content with a place on the bench.
It had been twelve years since Motherwell’s last opening day win at Fir Park and the initial signs didn’t look good as Hibs threatened early on.
Stokes got the better of Mark Reynolds inside the box and fired a low shot at goal but Darren Randolph was equal to it and diverted the ball behind.
The Steelmen recovered from the early scare and Murphy tried his luck with a low shot from 25 yards.
They then took the lead on 13 minutes when Sutton diverted a Tom Hateley cross past Graham Stack from close range.
And only a good save from the Hibs keeper prevented Sutton from doubling his and Motherwell’s advantage with a low shot from 12 yards.
Stack was called into action again 25 minutes when the lively Murphy let fly with another shot from the edge of the area. Murphy then turned provider for Sutton who saw his effort blocked in front of goal by Sol Bamba.
It was a terrific spell of pressure from the home side and they continued to unlock the Hibs defence as the half wore on.
Steven Saunders threatened to make it 2-0 from a Chris Humphrey corner but his towering header went just over the bar. Hateley then created space for himself on the edge of the area although his curling shot was easily held by Stack.
Hibs had offered very little going forward at this stage but they almost drew level when Kevin McBride combined with Derek Riordan.
The midfielder looked certain to score from 15 yards but Randolph stood tall and parried the ball behind.
However, the Motherwell keeper was beaten on the stroke of half-time when Stokes tapped home from close range after Riordan’s free-kick caused havoc inside the box.
It was cruel blow for the Steelmen, who were much the better team in the opening 45 minutes.
They hit-back after the break and Keith Lasley found Murphy with a superb cross-field ball but the striker’s shot was easily gathered by Stack.
Moments later Reynolds sent a 20-yard shot just wide of the keeper’s right-hand post as the second-half got off to a bright start.
At the other end and Stokes unleashed a curling effort which brought out the best in Randolph.
Play continued to flow from end to end and Humphrey went agonisingly close to restoring Motherwell’s lead when his looping cross struck the inside of the post.
Hibs failed to clear their lines and Humphrey sent the ball back into the danger area where Sutton headed just wide.
The Steelmen looked likelier to score but it was in fact Hibs who went in front on 64 minutes when Hanlon bundled a Riordan cross into the net from close range. Replays later showed the defender used his hand to help the ball over the line.
Motherwell were undone again on the counter-attack nine minutes later as the visitors extended their advantage. Riordan found Miller in the left-channel and he drilled the ball past Randolph and into the net.
But just like they did in the 6-6 draw at the end of last season, the Steelmen came fighting back.
Brown introduced Blackman for his debut and the substitute made an immediate impact – winning a penalty after having his shirt pulled by Nish.
Referee Craig Thomson, who earlier denied Sutton a penalty, pointed straight to the spot. Murphy stepped and sent Stack the wrong way to give his side hope.
But despite a late period of pressure, including a blocked shot from Lasley and header from Blackman, Hibs held on to claim all three points.
[tab:As it happened]
90+3′ FULL-TIME The referee signals the end of the game.
90+3′ Keith Lasley takes a shot. Blocked by David Stephens.
90+2′ Corner from left by-line taken short right-footed by Derek Riordan (Hibernian). Corner from left by-line taken short right-footed by Kevin McBride (Hibernian).
90+1′ Anthony Stokes takes a shot. Save by Darren Randolph.
89′ Derek Riordan produces a right-footed shot from deep inside the penalty box which goes wide of the left-hand post.
86′ Foul by Nick Blackman (Motherwell) on Michael Hart (Hibernian). Indirect free kick taken right-footed by Graham Stack (Hibernian) from own half.
86′ Foul by Anthony Stokes (Hibernian) on Stephen Craigan (Motherwell). Indirect free kick taken left-footed by Stephen Craigan (Motherwell) from own half, passed.
86′ Cross by Steven Saunders (Motherwell), header by Nick Blackman (Motherwell) from centre of penalty area (12 yards), missed left. Goal kick taken long by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
83′ SUB Chris Humphrey (Motherwell) leaves the field to be replaced by Esteban Casagolda.
84′ BOOKING Sol Bamba is cautioned by the ref for unsporting behaviour.
80′ Sol Bamba concedes a free kick for a foul on Nick Blackman. Stevie Hammell takes the direct free kick.
79′ Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on David Stephens by Mark Reynolds. Graham Stack takes the free kick.
79′ Shot by Derek Riordan (Hibernian) right-footed from centre of penalty area (12 yards), over the bar. Goal kick taken long by Darren Randolph (Motherwell).
79′ SUB David Stephens (Hibernian) comes on for Colin Nish.
75′ Foul by Chris Hogg (Hibernian) on John Sutton (Motherwell). Direct free kick taken right-footed by Jamie Murphy (Motherwell) from left channel, passed.
75′ Anthony Stokes challenges Stephen Craigan unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick taken by Darren Randolph.
75′ GOAL Jamie Murphy (Motherwell) scores from the penalty spot with a right-footed shot into the bottom-right corner of the goal.
74′ Kevin McBride challenges Nick Blackman unfairly and gives away a penalty.
74′ BOOKING Liam Miller is shown a yellow card.
74′ SUB Nick Blackman (Motherwell) replaces Tom Hateley.
73′ GOAL Liam Miller (Hibernian) scores with a right-footed shot into the bottom-left of the goal from left-side of the penalty area (12 yards).
70′ Foul by Paul Hanlon (Hibernian) on Chris Humphrey (Motherwell). Free kick crossed right-footed by Tom Hateley (Motherwell) from right wing, clearance by Kevin McBride (Hibernian).
70′ Paul Hanlon challenges Chris Humphrey unfairly and gives away a free kick.
68′ Effort on goal by Anthony Stokes from 20 yards. Darren Randolph makes a save.
65′ SUB Edwin De Graaf (Hibernian) is replaced by David Wotherspoon.
64′ GOAL Paul Hanlon (Hibernian) scores from the right side of six-yard box (4 yards). Assist by Derek Riordan.
64′ Inswinging corner from left by-line taken right-footed by Derek Riordan (Hibernian) to near post, clearance by Steven Saunders (Motherwell).
63′ Shot by Derek Riordan (Hibernian) volleyed left-footed from left side of penalty area (12 yards), save (parried) by Darren Randolph (Motherwell).
62′ Cross/shot by Chris Humphrey (Motherwell) hits the post. The ball is sent back over by Chris Humphrey, headed effort from inside the area by John Sutton (Motherwell) misses to the left of the target.
60′ Sol Bamba concedes a free kick for a foul on John Sutton. A cross is delivered by Stevie Hammell, Steven Saunders takes a shot. Graham Stack makes a save.
60′ Colin Nish concedes a free kick for a foul on Stephen Craigan. Darren Randolph takes the indirect free kick.
57′ Sol Bamba challenges John Sutton unfairly and gives away a free kick. Stevie Hammell restarts play with the free kick.
57′ Shot by Liam Miller (Hibernian) from 20 yards. Stephen Craigan gets a block in.
55′ Foul by Steve Jennings (Motherwell) on Anthony Stokes (Hibernian). Free kick crossed right-footed by Derek Riordan (Hibernian) from right wing, resulting in ball out of play. Goal kick taken long by Darren Randolph.
53′ Outswinging corner from right by-line taken right-footed by Chris Humphrey (Motherwell) to near post, save (caught) by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
52′ Foul by Colin Nish (Hibernian) on Tom Hateley (Motherwell). Direct free kick taken left-footed by Stevie Hammell (Motherwell) from own half, resulting in open play.
50′ Shot by Anthony Stokes (Hibernian) from 20 yards. Save made by Darren Randolph. Derek Riordan takes a outswinging corner from the right by-line to the near post, Paul Hanlon has a headed effort at goal from deep inside the area missing to the left of the target.
50′ Shot by Mark Reynolds (Motherwell) drilled right-footed from left channel (30 yards), missed left. Goal kick taken long by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
48′ The referee blows for offside. Darren Randolph takes the indirect free kick. Foul by Souleymane Bamba on Jamie Murphy, free kick awarded. The free kick is delivered right-footed by Tom Hateley from right channel, Colin Nish makes a clearance.
48′ Shot by Jamie Murphy (Motherwell) drilled right-footed from centre of penalty area (20 yards), save (caught) by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
47′ Steven Saunders (Motherwell) caught offside. Indirect free kick taken right-footed by Graham Stack (Hibernian) from own half, resulting in open play.
46′ Inswinging corner from left by-line taken right-footed by Tom Hateley (Motherwell) to far post, clearance by Chris Hogg (Hibernian).
46′ KICK-OFF The second half begins.
45+2′ HALF-TIME The first half comes to an end.
45+1′ GOAL Anthony Stokes (Hibernian) grabs a goal from close range to the bottom-left corner of the goal. Assist by Sol Bamba.
45+1′ Foul by Keith Lasley (Motherwell) on Anthony Stokes (Hibernian). Direct free kick taken right-footed by Derek Riordan (Hibernian) from left channel,
45+1 John Sutton (Motherwell) is caught offside. Indirect free kick taken right-footed by Graham Stack (Hibernian) from own half, resulting in open play.
43′ Colin Nish concedes a free kick for a foul on Stephen Craigan. Darren Randolph takes the free kick.
41′ Free kick awarded for a foul by Mark Reynolds on Anthony Stokes. Paul Hanlon sends in a cross, Chris Hogg produces a header from inside the area that goes over the bar.
40′ Tom Hateley takes a shot. Save by Graham Stack.
38′ Shot by Kevin McBride (Hibernian). Save by Darren Randolph. Corner taken right-footed by Derek Riordan from the right by-line, Stevie Hammell manages to make a clearance.
35′ The offside flag is raised against Colin Nish (Hibernian). Free kick taken by Darren Randolph.
35′ Tom Hateley (Motherwell) takes a shot. Save made by Graham Stack.
29′ Outswinging corner from right by-line taken right-footed by Chris Humphrey (Motherwell) to far post, header by Steven Saunders (Motherwell) from centre of penalty area (6 yards), over the bar. Goal kick taken long by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
25′ Shot by Jamie Murphy (Motherwell) volleyed right-footed from left channel (20 yards), save (caught) by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
24′ Goal kick taken long by Darren Randolph (Motherwell).
24′ Stevie Hammell gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Anthony Stokes. Chris Hogg takes the direct free kick.
18′ Anthony Stokes fouled by Keith Lasley, the ref awards a free kick. Shot comes in from Derek Riordan from the free kick.
18′ Effort on goal from 12 yards by John Sutton (Motherwell). Graham Stack makes a save.
17′ Foul by Sol Bamba (Hibernian) on Keith Lasley (Motherwell). Direct free kick taken right-footed by Stephen Craigan (Motherwell) from right wing, resulting in open play.
13′ GOAL John Sutton scores from inside the six-yard box to the bottom-right corner of the goal. Assist by Tom Hateley.
12′ The referee blows for offside against Hibernian. Free kick taken by Darren Randolph.
12′ Goal kick taken short by Graham Stack (Hibernian).
11′ Handball by Kevin McBride (Hibernian). Indirect free kick taken left-footed by Stevie Hammell (Motherwell) from own half, resulting in open play.
10′ John Sutton (Motherwell) caught offside. Indirect free kick taken right-footed by Graham Stack (Hibernian) from own half, resulting in open play.
9′ Jamie Murphy (Motherwell) has an effort at goal from 35 yards. Save made by Graham Stack.
7′ Free kick awarded for a foul by Keith Lasley on Sol Bamba. Paul Hanlon takes the indirect free kick.
5′ Derek Riordan takes the outswinging corner, clearance made by Stephen Craigan.
5′ Anthony Stokes (Hibernian) takes a shot from 12 yards. Save by Darren Randolph.
2′ Chris Humphrey takes a outswinging corner to the near post, clearance by Michael Hart.
1′ KICK-OFF The game gets underway
[tab:Reaction]
Motherwell boss Craig Brown:
“I think the penalty we got was the least obvious of three good penalty claims. But I think Craig Thomson is a good referee so I don’t want to criticise him. We have to fault ourselves for not finishing the job.
“We had the chances in the first-half to be in an unassailable lead, if in a Motherwell-Hibs game any lead is unassailable.
“We fault ourselves for not taking those chances and give credit to Hibs, they battled their way back.
“The game should have been out of sight and then we didn’t get a break in terms of decisions. We got one penalty but there was one after it and one before it.
“I said to my colleague Archie (Knox) ‘Aberdeen got three in the one game’. But, as a rule, you don’t get three penalties.”
Hibs boss John Hughes:
“In the first half, it was all Motherwell. Then we got a foothold in the game and started playing some football.
“We’ve got goals in our team and these guys are spirited and want to score goals. Their keeper has produced two or three great saves and I’m delighted we’ve picked up three points.
“I’ve seen us play better football but it was a case of doing what we had to do to win the football match.”
Motherwell midfielder Keith Lasley:
“We didn’t get the breaks. At the second goal I couldn’t tell what had happened, but Stevie (Hammell) claimed for a handball and so did a couple of the other boys. Perhaps the linesman didn’t have a great view of it.
“It’s another aspect of the game that we will look at and think it is another bit of luck which has gone against us.
“The bottom line is we have lost the game, that’s it. The outcome is we have gained no points and it’s already in the past – we now have to take it on with the chin and get on with preparing for the next match.”
[tab:Man-of-the-match]
[poll id=”5″]